(Justin Sullivan/Getty Images) The north tower of the Golden Gate Bridge is seen surrounded by fog on September 8, 2013, in San Francisco.
San Francisco's
fog is famous,
especially in the summer, when weather conditions combine to create the
characteristic cooling blanket that sits over the Bay Area.
But one fact many may not know about San Francisco's fog is that in
1950, the US military conducted a test to see whether it could be used
to help spread a biological weapon in a "simulated germ-warfare attack." This was just the start of many such tests around the country that would go on in secret for years.
But, as she writes, it was also "one of the largest offenses of the Nuremberg Code since its inception."
The code stipulates that "voluntary, informed consent" is required
for research participants, and that experiments that might lead to death
or disabling injury are unacceptable.
The unsuspecting residents of San Francisco certainly could not
consent to the military's germ-warfare test, and there's good evidence
that it could have caused the death of at least one resident of the
city, Edward Nevin, and hospitalized 10 others.
This is a crazy story; one that seems like it must be a conspiracy
theory. An internet search will reveal plenty of misinformation and
unbelievable conjecture about these experiments. But the core of this
incredible tale is documented and true.
'A successful biological warfare attack'
It all began in late September 1950, when over a few days, a Navy
vessel used giant hoses to spray a fog of two kinds of bacteria,
Serratia marcescens and Bacillus globigii — both believed at the time to
be harmless — out into the fog, where they disappeared and spread over
the city.
"It was noted that a successful
BW [biological warfare] attack on this area can be launched from the
sea, and that effective dosages can be produced over relatively large
areas," concluded a later-declassified military report,
cited by the Wall Street Journal.
Successful indeed, according to
Leonard Cole, the director of the Terror Medicine and Security Program at Rutgers New Jersey Medical School. His book, "
Clouds of Secrecy," documents the military's secret bioweapon tests over populated areas. Cole wrote:
Nearly all of San Francisco received 500
particle minutes per liter. In other words, nearly every one of the
800,000 people in San Francisco exposed to the cloud at normal breathing
rate (10 liters per minute) inhaled 5,000 or more particles per minute
during the several hours that they remained airborne.
This was among the first but far from the last of these sorts of tests.
(Flickr/Roman Kruglov)
Tests
included the large-scale releases of bacteria in the New York City
subway system, on the Pennsylvania Turnpike, and in National Airport.
Over the next 20 years, the military would conduct
239 "germ-warfare" tests over populated areas,
according to news reports from the 1970s (after the secret tests had
been revealed) in The New York Times, The Washington Post, Associated
Press, and other publications (via Lexis-Nexis), and also detailed in
congressional testimony from the 1970s.
These tests included the large-scale releases of bacteria in the New
York City subway system, on the Pennsylvania Turnpike, and in National
Airport just outside Washington, DC.
In a 1994 congressional
testimony, Cole said that none of this had been revealed to the public
until a 1976 newspaper story revealed the story of a few of the first
experiments — though at least a Senate subcommittee had heard testimony
about experiments in New York City in 1975, according to a 1995 Newsday
report.
A mysterious death
When Edward Nevin III, the
grandson of the Edward Nevin who died in 1950, read about one of those
early tests in San Francisco, he connected the story to his
grandfather's death from a mysterious bacterial infection. He began to
try to convince the government to reveal more data about these
experiments. In 1977, they released a report
detailing more of that activity.
(Dbn/Wikimedia Commons) Serratia marcescens turns bread red as a bacterial colony grows.
In
1950, the first Edward Nevin had been recovering from a prostate
surgery when he suddenly fell ill with a severe urinary-tract infection
containing Serratia marcescens, the theoretically harmless
bacterium that's known for turning bread red in color. The bacteria had
reportedly never been found in the hospital before and was rare in the
Bay Area (and in California in general).
The bacteria spread to Nevin's heart and he died a few weeks later.
Another 10 patients showed up in
the hospital over the next few months, all with pneumonia symptoms and
the odd presence of Serratia marcescens. They all recovered.
Nevin's grandson
tried to sue
the government for wrongful death, but the court held that the
government was immune to a lawsuit for negligence and that they were
justified in conducting tests without subjects' knowledge. According to
The Wall Street Journal,
the Army stated that infections must have occurred inside the hospital
and the US Attorney argued that they had to conduct tests in a populated
area to see how a biological agent would affect that area.
In 2005,
the FDA stated
that "Serratia marcescens bacteria ... can cause serious,
life-threatening illness in patients with compromised immune systems."
The bacteria has shown up in a few other Bay Area health crises since
the 1950s,
according to The San Francisco Chronicle, leading to some speculation that the original spraying could have established a new microbial population in the area.
While Nevin lost his lawsuit, he said afterward,
as quoted by Cole, "At least we are all aware of what can happen, even in this country ... I just hope the story won’t be forgotten."